How to make Peanut Butter with Crunchy Perfection, Easy Homemade Recipe

My Crunchy Peanut Butter Obsession

If you’re anything like me, there’s something magical about making peanut butter with crunchy texture at home. This recipe isn’t just tasty, it’s clean, quick, and deeply satisfying. From choosing the right peanuts to customizing the flavor, you’re about to become the nut butter boss.

Let’s dive into how to make peanut butter with crunchy texture from scratch, why roasting matters, and how it compares nutritionally to creamy styles. Bonus: you’ll learn pro tips on how to store and serve it.

On the page

Nana’s Saturday Recipe Box

My journey with peanut butter with crunchy roots back to Saturdays with my Nana. We’d roast peanuts, crush them by hand, and fold them into the smooth batch just before spooning it into jars. Our hands were messy, and the kitchen smelled divine. We’d swirl in cinnamon or a pinch of salt, but the highlight was always the crunch.

Today, I recreate that nostalgic peanut butter with crunchy magic in my dessert studio above a flower shop in Northampton. And I promise once you make your own, the jarred stuff won’t cut it anymore.

Print

Peanut Butter with Crunchy Perfection – Easy Homemade Recipe

5 Stars 4 Stars 3 Stars 2 Stars 1 Star

No reviews

Homemade peanut butter with crunchy texture using roasted peanuts, a hint of cinnamon, and optional coconut sugar for natural sweetness.

  • Author: Ghalya Peaches
  • Prep Time: 5 minutes
  • Cook Time: 10 minutes
  • Total Time: 15 minutes
  • Yield: 1 jar
  • Category: Nut Butter, Spread
  • Method: Blended
  • Cuisine: American
  • Diet: Vegan

Ingredients

Scale

3 cups organic raw or unsalted roasted peanuts

¼½ teaspoon salt (optional)

¼ teaspoon ground cinnamon (optional)

12 teaspoons coconut sugar (optional)

Instructions

1. If using raw peanuts, preheat oven to 180C/350F. Roast for 10–15 minutes until golden and aromatic. Let cool.

2. Pulse ⅓ cup of roasted peanuts in a dry blender until coarsely ground. Set aside.

3. Place remaining peanuts into blender. Select nut mode or blend for 1 minute using tamper.

4. Scrape down sides. Add cinnamon, salt, and coconut sugar if using.

5. Blend for another 1–1½ minutes until glossy and smooth.

6. Fold in reserved crushed peanuts.

7. Transfer to a clean glass jar and cool before sealing.

8. Store in fridge up to 4 weeks.

Notes

Avoid adding liquid sweeteners directly to the blender to prevent seizing. For smoother blending, use freshly roasted peanuts.

Did you make this recipe?

Don’t forget to rate this recipe and share a photo below. Can’t wait to see your delicious creations!

Homemade Over Store-Bought

Store-bought peanut butter often hides behind additives: stabilizers, oils, and unnecessary sugars. But making peanut butter with crunchy texture at home means total control. Just peanuts, maybe cinnamon, a little coconut sugar done.

Roasted peanuts work best, unlocking deep nutty flavor. I even used this method to inspire the nutty layers in my Cinnamon Roll Focaccia Bread. Homemade peanut butter with crunchy bits isn’t just healthier it’s wildly more flavorful.

Crunch Factor , Creating Texture That Pops

How to Get That Signature Crunch

o make true peanut butter with crunchy character, crush a portion of peanuts separately before blending. I pulse 1/3 cup of roasted peanuts until coarsely ground then stir them into the creamy base at the end. It gives you the perfect ratio of smooth to crunchy in every bite.

The process is fast. With a Vibe Blender, whole nuts turn into glossy butter in just minutes. The key? Blend the rest of your peanuts until they turn creamy, glossy, and pourable, then fold in the reserved crunch.

Flavor Boosts: Cinnamon & Coconut Sugar

Want to elevate your peanut butter with crunchy spread? Stir in ¼ teaspoon of cinnamon and 1 to 2 teaspoons of coconut sugar. The cinnamon warms up the flavor, and the sugar adds just a touch of sweetness without overdoing it.

Avoid maple syrup or honey in the blender, it’ll dry out the mix. If you need sweetness, blend first, then stir in with a little coconut oil.

Step-by-step collage of making peanut butter with crunchy texture using roasted peanuts and a blender

Need more healthy flavor tips? I use the same approach in my easy healthy desserts, where natural ingredients shine. Check out our facebook page for more recipes.

Health Talk – Is Crunchy Peanut Butter Actually Better?

Crunchy vs. Creamy: A Nutritional Comparison

So, is peanut butter with crunchy the healthier option? Surprisingly, it often is. When comparing natural versions not the store-bought sugary stuff, crunchy peanut butter usually edges out creamy by a sliver in fiber and protein content. Why? Because those extra peanut pieces haven’t been fully processed, preserving a bit more of their structure, and therefore, nutrition.

For example, 2 tablespoons of natural crunchy peanut butter often contain:

  • 8g protein
  • 2g fiber
  • Healthy monounsaturated fats
  • Vitamin E, magnesium, and potassium

Creamy peanut butter? Nearly identical, but slightly lower in fiber. The difference is modest, but if you’re looking to feel full longer, crunch might be your ally. And hey, if the texture helps you eat it slower, even better.

If you’re pairing it with homemade cinnamon bread, a dollop of crunchy can help balance the sweetness and add satiety.

Avoiding the Additive Trap

Here’s where homemade wins, by a landslide. Many store-bought peanut butter seven the ones labeled “natural” often contain palm oil, sweeteners, or emulsifiers. These ingredients can turn a healthful snack into a processed food bomb. When you make your own peanut butter with crunchy texture, you skip all that.

Control is everything. You decide whether to add cinnamon for blood sugar balance, coconut sugar for a gentle sweetness, or nothing at all. Just clean, whole peanuts and a blender.

You can even experiment with salt-free versions, which I often recommend in my sugar-free baking workshops. They have a cleaner taste that lets the true peanut flavor stand out.

For anyone watching their sugar intake, keeping the recipe clean makes it keto- and Whole30-friendly just pure roasted peanuts, blended into bliss.

The Final Jar: Storing, Serving & Shelf Life Tips

From Blender to Jar: Best Storage Practices

Once your peanut butter with crunchy texture is just right creamy with bold peanut chunks it’s time to store it properly. Homemade nut butter doesn’t contain preservatives, so your storage method matters. First, make sure the jar you use is squeaky clean and completely dry. Moisture invites spoilage.

Two jars of peanut butter, one creamy and one with crunchy bits, surrounded by scattered peanuts

Let your peanut butter cool to room temperature before sealing the lid. Then, store it in the fridge for longer life up to 4 weeks. If you prefer it softer and spreadable straight from the jar, a dark, cool pantry works too. Just make sure it’s used up in 2–3 weeks.

And yes, it will naturally separate! That’s a good sign. Just stir and spread. No stabilizers here just real ingredients.

This simple storage trick is something I often apply in my Holiday Baking Prep Tips too. Whether it’s dough or nut butter, the same logic applies: fresh wins.

Delicious Ways to Serve It

You can enjoy peanut butter with crunchy so many ways:

  • Spread on toast with banana slices
  • Swirled into hot oatmeal
  • Spooned onto pancakes or muffins
  • Rolled into oat bites with dates
  • Dolloped onto focaccia cinnamon rolls

Which peanut butter is the crunchiest?

Homemade peanut butter with coarse, freshly pulsed nuts tends to be crunchier than store-bought. You control the texture, making it as chunky as you like.

Is crunchy peanut butter healthier?

Yes crunchy peanut butter often has slightly more fiber and a bit less processing, which helps retain some nutrients.

Which peanut butter is better, crunchy or creamy?

It depends on preference. Crunchy offers texture and more fiber, while creamy spreads more easily. Both have similar nutritional value.

What is the crunchy part in crunchy peanut butter?

t’s simply crushed or chopped peanuts that are mixed back into smooth peanut butter, giving it that signature bite.

Our Readers Love these Recipes !

Slice of rich chocolate cake made by baking with protein powder
June 21, 2025

Baking with Protein Powder: A Deliciously Useful Guide for High-Protein Treats

How My Protein Baking Journey Began Incorporating more baking with protein powder into your desserts doesn’t have to mean choking
Read more
Vanilla quarter sheet cake decorated as an American flag with strawberries and blueberries
June 21, 2025

Vanilla Quarter Sheet Cake That Melts in Your Mouth

The Story Behind My Vanilla Quarter Sheet Cake A vanilla quarter sheet cake is that no fuss, crowd-pleasing dessert that
Read more
Glass jar of peanut butter with crunchy texture, surrounded by raw peanuts and a spoon dripping with creamy spread
June 21, 2025

How to make Peanut Butter with Crunchy Perfection, Easy Homemade Recipe

Peanut butter with crunchy texture made easy! This homemade recipe uses roasted peanuts and zero additives. Full flavor, natural ingredients, no compromise.
Read more

Leave a Comment

Recipe rating 5 Stars 4 Stars 3 Stars 2 Stars 1 Star